Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison of performance of suspended- and attached-growth systems

From: Lipid production by the filamentous cyanobacterium Limnothrix sp. growing in synthetic wastewater in suspended- and attached-growth photobioreactor systems

 

Suspended systema

Attached systema

Suspended systemb

Attached systemb

Maximum biomass*

141 mg/L

2.5 g/m2 (89.68 mg/L)

291 mg/L

5.2 g/m2 (190.5 mg/L)

Total biomass in PBR

141 mg/L

7.24 g/m2** (252 mg/L)**

291 mg/L

22.12 g/m2** (770 mg/L)**

Maximum oil*

32 mg/L

0.6 g/m2 (21.44 mg/L)

43 mg/L

0.5 g/m2 (17.47 mg/L)

Total oil in PBR

32 mg/L

1.52 g/m2*** (52.94 g/L)***

43 mg/L

1.58 g/m2*** 54.46 mg/L***

Oil in biomass on glass rods (%)

–

24.14

–

14.12

Oil in total biomass of PBR (%)

26.89

21.01

16.8

7.07

Total biomass productivity (mg/L∙day)

20.14

38.77

22.38

35.00

Total biomass productivity (g/m2·day)

–

1.11

–

1.01

Total oil productivity (mg/L∙day)

4.57

8.14

3.31

2.48

Total oil productivity (g/m2 ∙day)

–

0.23

–

0.07

NO3 − removal (%)

93.05

80.90

96.69

96.92

PO4 −2 removal (%)

98.86

98.54

93.14

98.81

Total surface of glass rods (m2)

–

0.1276

–

0.1276

Total surface of PBR walls (m2)

–

0.1199

–

0.1199

Total surface of PBR (rods and walls) (m2)

–

0.2475

–

0.2475

Volume of PBR (mL)

3500

3500

3500

3500

Cultivation time (days)

7

6.5

13

22

  1. aKinetic experiment under low nutrient concentrations (Fig. 2)
  2. bKinetic experiment under high nutrient concentrations (Fig. 3)
  3. *Concentration at the end of the experiment. In the case of suspended cultivation, maximum biomass is equal to total biomass and maximum oil is equal to total oil.
  4. **Sum of attached biomass on glass rods and PBR walls
  5. ***Sum of produced oil on glass rods and PBR walls