Skip to main content

Table 3 Relative abundance of phylogenetic order under the Phylum of Proteobacteria at each experimental site (relative abundance > 1%)

From: Different fertilization treatments in coal mining-affected soils change bacterial populations and enable soil reclamation

Order

 

Samples(%)

  

INI

CK1

M1

O1

MO1

CK5

M5

O5

MO5

FS

Rhizobiales

1.86b

5.74a

5.83a

6.22a

5.16a

4.95a

4.97a

5.32a

4.82a

5.82a

Myxococcales

2.16b

4.45a

5.84a

5.53a

3.97a

4.08a

4.40a

4.65a

4.43a

4.81a

Sphingomonadales

0.98c

5.58ab

6.84a

5.07ab

4.64b

3.72b

4.54b

4.50b

4.27b

3.74b

Xanthomonadales

1.34d

5.48b

7.19a

4.68bc

3.16c

2.98cd

3.86bc

3.38c

4.43bc

3.48c

Burkholderiales

1.74e

4.87a

3.98abc

4.27ab

3.12bcd

2.04de

2.15de

3.02cd

1.38e

1.68e

Rhodospirillales

0.77c

2.71b

2.77b

3.03b

3.64ab

3.28ab

3.44ab

3.51ab

3.41ab

4.37a

  1. Values followed by different letters are considered significantly different (p < 0.05) according to Duncan’s multiple comparison test. INI initial soil without treatment, CK1 and CK5 no fertilizer for 1 and 5 years, respectively, M1 and M5 1 year and 5 years of mineral fertilizer, O1 and O5 1 year and 5 years of organic fertilizer, MO1 and MO5 1 year and 5 years of combined of inorganic and organic fertilization, FS normal farmland soil without land subsidence